Investment treaty arbitration is fast becoming one of the most common methods of dispute settlement in international law. Unidroit principles of international commercial contracts picc, icsid, investment arbitration, general principles of law, bilateral investment treaties bits, international investment. From 20002004, he served as chief of the nafta arbitration division in the office of the legal adviser, united states department of state. There are various types of claims that may be presented to arbitration in the context of an investment treaty and the same principles do not necessarily extend to all such claims so one must beware of overgeneralizing. The host states consent to the jurisdiction of icsid is. The principles and practice of international commercial arbitration by professor margaret l. The convergence of international trade and investment arbitration. The third party funder as such has no interest in the substantive issues of the arbitral proceedings, but instead invests in the proceedings hoping to make a considerable profit upon the settlement of the dispute. Practitioners and scholars in one field rarely labor in the vineyards of the other. Introduction no issue in the field of investment arbitration is more fundamental, or more disputed, than the distinction between treaty and contract. It provides access to a number of indispensable economic resources. Investment treaty arbitration as public international law. Without reference to a conflict of laws system voie. General principles of law and international investment arbitration programme may 29th, friday aula e, palazzo del bo 9.
A relatively recent phenomenon in international investment arbitration is the financing of the proceedings by a third party funder. Different situation in commercial and investment arbitrations 1 16 determination of applicable laws. Enter your mobile number or email address below and well send you a link to download the free kindle app. In particular, some decisions have interpreted the new york convention as requiring the application of a nondiscrimination principle, forbidding the application of idiosyncratic or discriminatory national law rules that. Sovereign immunity from jurisdiction or from execution. The book provides a detailed analytical survey of the developing substantive principles which are being applied to disputes by international investment tribunals. Foreign investors are much more willing to pursue a claim of, e. The possibility for a foreign investor to sue a host state is a guarantee for the foreign investor that, in the case of a dispute, it will have access to independent and qualified arbitrators who will solve the dispute and render an.
International investment arbitration and the rule of law. Feb 23, 2015 law and practice of investment treaties. Domestic law in international investment arbitration by jarrod hepburn, published by oxford university press, april 2017. Legum gratefully acknowledges the assistance of annesophie dufetre in preparing these remarks for publication. Investment treaty arbitration as public international law by. Everyday low prices and free delivery on eligible orders. The future of investment arbitration by christoph schreuer a. General approach arbitration awards are always based on substantive rules of law, applicable to the relationship between the parties. A subject and a sovereign are clean different things.
We will conclude the course with a module on the interplay between state immunity and enforcement of arbitral awards. Isds or the international investment regime is public. This is sometimes called the curial law or lex arbitri. The law applicable in investment treaty arbitration. Due to the widespread geographical participation of states in investment treaties and the increased use of arbitration to settle disputes involving significant amounts of money, understanding the particularities and dynamics.
The relevance of the u principles of international. The relevance of the u principles of international commercial. This is the longawaited second edition of this widelyreferenced work on the substantive law principles of investment treaty arbitration. Third party funding in international investment arbitration. Note, general principles of law in international commercial. Substantive principles is an important step in this process. Substantive principles oxford international arbitration series 2 by mclachlan, campbell, shore, laurence, weiniger, matthew isbn. L shore and m weiniger, international investment arbitration. Substantive principles oxford, 2007 g van harten, investment treaty arbitration and public law oxford, 2006.
We will conclude the course with a module on the interplay between state immunity and enforcement of. Basic principles of investment law and arbitration arbitration agreements without privity and sovereign immunity 1 6 issues covered. Investment treaties and general international law volume 57 issue 2 campbell mclachlan. As investment treaties typically have similar provisions and investment awards often become public, investment treaty arbitration has developed a robust system of quasiprecedents, with the citation to and analysis of. Due to the widespread geographical participation of states in investment treaties and the increased use of arbitration to settle disputes involving significant amounts of money, understanding the particularities and. With reference to a conflict of laws system voie indirecte. Foreign investment and development there is broad consensus, that foreign investment is an important if not the most important factor in economic development. The notion of investment in international investment law 43 investment would be kept. Investment treaty arbitration as a species of global. The japanphilippines epa, the aseanindia treaty, the aseankorea treaty, and the aanz fta.
Investment treaty arbitration and international law. Weiniger 2008 this useful resource for practitioners, academics and arbitrators includes a good description of the present state of international investment law as reflected in tribunal practice. Investment arbitration is arbitration in investment disputes between foreign investors and the host state which finds place within the framework of either a bilateral investment treaty bit between the host state and the investors state or a multilateral treaty, such as the nafta or the energy charter treaty. The convention on the settlement of investment disputes between states and nationals of other states hereinafter. International arbitration the key elements a presentation by charles manzoni. Apr 12, 2017 the features of the investment arbitration process that can be seen to align with lord binghams eight principles include the accessibility of clearly expressed international arbitration law and of reasoned decisions of tribunals. Together they provide an effective web of protections and recourse to international investors. This volume contains the papers and proceedings of the 10th anniversary juris conference. International investment cases show the frequent use of good faith arguments by both investors and respondent states. General principles of law and international investment. The investors consent to arbitration is often found in the investors request for arbitration. For an entire module, we will focus on investment arbitration, its principles and the procedure of the icsid, the international centre for settlement of investment disputes. Substantive principles, also contain sound analysis and useful advice.
Since investment arbitration is a mechanism for solving disputes between foreign investors and the 1 international institute for the uni. Charles i, speech on the scaffold, 30 january 16491 1. These treaties include substantive and procedural rules to provide investment security. Investment treaty arbitration as a species of global administrative law 123 the article will proceed by analysing the four distinctive features of investment treaty arbitration or investment arbitration as a manifestation of global administrative law. Jun 12, 2017 domestic law in international investment arbitration by jarrod hepburn, published by oxford university press, april 2017. Principles of investment treaty arbitration investment. Human rights and international investment arbitration. Yet the trade and investment arbitration regimes routinely. Recent years, there has been an extraordinary increase in the number of investment arbitration for breach of bilateral investment treaties bits. Substantive protections procedural rights fair and equitable treatment fet.
Substantive principles is an important contribution to the collection and codification of the current state of practice in this field. Investment arbitration is possibly the fastestdeveloping area of international law, combining elements of private dispute settlement, treaty law and public policy. Our group of 10 authors again take contrary positions and grapple with the dramatic developments of investment arbitration over the past 10 years. Arbitration of the international chamber of commerce, based in paris. The notion of investment in international investment law. These substantive differences have, in turn, led to procedural divergences between investment and commercial arbitration. Drawing on case law, international law principles and comparative analysis, this book addresses when and how investment tribunals should engage with domestic law. The convergence of international trade and investment. Standards of treatment, as well as international investment arbitration.
Investment arbitration is a procedure to resolve disputes between foreign investors and host states also called investorstate dispute settlement or isds. Download international investment arbitration substantive principles oxford international arbitration series in pdf and epub formats for free. This book chapter published in the leading publication on arbitration in the uk, offers an insider view of the london court of international arbitration lcia and its rules of arbitration. The development of international arbitration on bilateral.
This dissertation analyses developments of international arbitration on investment disputes. Divergence between investment and commercial arbitration by. International investment arbitration substantive principles oxford international arbitration series book also available for read online, mobi, docx and mobile and kindle reading. The relevance of the unidroit principles of international commercial contracts in international investment arbitration august reinisch abstract the unidroit principles of international commercial contracts picc have played a relatively unnoticed role. International arbitral rules generally allow parties to an agreement containing an arbitration clause to choose the substantive law that will govern disputes. It considers the key questions that arise, and provides a clear description of the. This approach does not determine minimum conditions for the notion of investment and it does not establish an applicable test for the purposes of icsid jurisdiction. The legal principles that have developed in investment arbitration are subject to intense debate and are still in a state of flux. Then you can start reading kindle books on your smartphone, tablet.
Divergence between investment and commercial arbitration. Introduction international trade and investment arbitration are distinct disciplines within the field of international economic law. Domestic law in international investment arbitration. The convergence of international trade and investment arbitration 37 i. These cases also illustrate how parties and tribunals tend to conceptualize the good faith principle which has become an. The law applicable in investment treaty arbitration yas banifatemi the inquiry into the law applicable to a dispute seems, on its face, a fairly simple question.
International investment arbitration hardcover campbell. Investment treaty arbitration denial of benefits to. This paper addresses principles relating to compensation in the context of claims arising under investment treaties. The popularity of arbitration for this purpose has not only led to a rapid increase in. General principles of law in investment arbitration surveys the function of general principles in the field of international investment law, particularly in investment arbitration.
Assessment of its substantive and procedural value abstract. Introduction investment arbitration has emerged as the most effective means of resolving investorstate disputes. R dolzer and c schreuer, principles of international investment law oxford, 2008 c mclachlan qc, l shore, m weiniger, and l mistelis, international investment arbitration. Despite having ancient roots, tensions remain between the private interests in international investment relations and the public international law features of the arbitral procedure.
The objective of the thesis is thus to evaluate the current practice with regards to the use of the sovereign immunity defense during enforcement of icsid awards and whether, and if yes, to what extent this impacts the efficiency of investment arbitration under the convention. Investment treaty law and arbitration fall term 2011. In doing so, we will seek to demonstrate the scope and potency of this. Investment treaty arbitration books by international. The law applicable to an issue relating to the procedure of the arbitration is the investment treaty, the applicable arbitration rules and, in some cases, the law of the seat of the. Commercial arbitration is based on an arbitration agreement, whereas investment arbitration may be based either on a an investment treaty, either multi or bilateral bit, b the host states national investment law, which often provides for protection of foreign investors or c in certain circumstances, an investment agreement. The nature of international investment law 19 a investment law and trade law 19 b balancing duties and benefits 20 c the investors perspective. Human rights and international investment arbitration by clara reiner1 and christoph schreuer2 i. With tpp and ttip on the horizon, half of our authors take the view that the field is a doomed experiment and the other half of our authors.
Investment arbitration is arbitration in investment disputes between foreign investors and the host state which finds place within the framework of either a bilateral investment treaty bit between the host state and the investors state or a multilateral treaty. Investment treaty protection and investment arbitration have become cornerstones of international investment law. The authors analysis provides a representative case study of how this informal source operates alongside and in the absence of other sources of applicable law. Given the fundamental principle of party autonomy in international arbitration, the arbitrators. Key issues and recent developments in international. Subjective arbitrability and investment law arbitration. A question of substantive protection, rather than jurisdiction.
782 122 1209 1364 1545 1442 1131 1565 903 1597 33 582 1003 116 127 1356 1442 1599 122 788 1419 1181 75 592 1566 250 955 133 402 41 500 428 1189 450 1288